Pros And Cons Of Replacing Sarfraz Ahmed With Shoaib Malik

The debate on whether Sarfraz Ahmed should be replaced with Shoaib Malik to lead the green shirts during the world cup began as soon as the former was banned by the ICC under its anti-racism code and the later was able to clinch a comprehensive victory against the Proteas in the fourth ODI of the series. So, here is a look at the pros and cons of replacing Sarfraz Ahmed with Shoaib Malik as the skipper to lead the men in green during the mega event.

Read: 3 Talking Points From Sarfraz Ahmed’s 4 Match Ban

At least A Better Chance In The World Cup

Shoaib Malik looked better composed while leading Pakistan at Johannesburg. Unlike Sarfraz he did not have feedback to give every second ball. Bowlers too under him, looked extremely comfortable while going about their business. Moreover, he has enough experience and exposure to  avoid unwanted incidents like the one Sarfraz got himself into.

Finally, with the world cup being Malik’s final ODI assignment; as he has already announced his ODI retirement following the tournament; Malik has nothing to lose and therefore, Pakistan under him will probably, have a better chance of clinching the trophy.

Read: Sarfraz Ahmed In Serious Trouble: Skipper’s Decisions And Behavior Likely To Have Repercussions 

A Short Term Solution

For Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) however, Malik’s appointment would be a short term solution. Once the world cup ends PCB will have to look for a new captain and hence, deal with unnecessary politics with in the team that is generally evident every time the top position goes vacant. Appointing Malik then, might provide temporary relief but not without long term repercussions.

Read: Removal Of Sarfraz Ahmed And Mickey Arthur: Why It Won’t Help!

Can’t Have The Same Captain Across Formats

PCB most definitely wants to have the same guy leading Pakistan in all formats owing to the fact that the green caps generally struggle every time they have different skippers leading them. Since, Malik has retired from Test cricket and because he won’t be available to lead even in the ODIs after the world cup; there is no way PCB will be able to employ the one captain in all formats formula.

Read: 5 Interesting Things You Must Know About Today’s Google Doodle, Abdul Hafeez Kardar!

Verdict

Hence, given the scenario PCB is likely to stick with Sarfraz at least till the world cup that takes place later in the year in England and later appoint someone else if needed. Nevertheless, if Malik is able to secure an ODI and T20 series victory in South Africa the probability of PCB giving a second thought cannot really be ruled out, at this point in time.