Funny man, Vasay Chaudhry was not in a particularly funny mood last evening when he sent out a series of six tweets detailing his reasons for resigning from Punjab’s Cultural Advisory Council.
Vasay, who, along with film star Shaan Shahid and veteran director Syed Noor had been serving on the council for the last three months, decided to step down from his advisory role after he felt that most of the recommendations made by him and others on the panel were not being given serious consideration.
1/1 I have been a part of the cultural advisory council (Punjab) more specifically the Film sub committee(along with Mr.Shaan,Syed Noor and Rashid kh Sb )since last 3 months.This committee was formed by the minister for Culture.
During this time We offered multiple suggestions— vasay chaudhry (@vasaych) January 13, 2019
1/2 some of which are as follows
1)offering medical services to veteran artists.
Im pleased to share that by the grace of god & support from CM punjab, Health cards are now being issued to artists across the province.— vasay chaudhry (@vasaych) January 13, 2019
1/3
2) I also suggested to introduce a Lahore Film Festival with participants from various countries.
3)It was also suggested that a film authority be formed in Punjab offering benefits (subsidies,permissions etc)to help film production & revival of the film industry in Punjab.— vasay chaudhry (@vasaych) January 13, 2019
1/4
4) Re structuring of the Taxes on Cinemas in Punjab along with suggestions to curtail the cinema mafia.( comprising of ideas/suggestions to benefit the Pakistani film Producers so they can produce more films )— vasay chaudhry (@vasaych) January 13, 2019
1/5 ..the reason i mentioned all these things because I feel a moral obligation even if it's in the capacity of an advisor as i believe that i'm accountable for my performance because its the tax payers money which was utilised in those long sessions & meetings.
— vasay chaudhry (@vasaych) January 13, 2019
1/6 having said that I will be stepping down frm the cultural advisory council as there is No point in sitting around when the carefully & passionately thought out paperwork is Not being forwarded or implemented for reasons best known to the Cultural ministry.
Pakistan Zindabad— vasay chaudhry (@vasaych) January 13, 2019
He acknowledged that his suggestion pertaining to the provision of health services to veteran actors had been realized and that actors across the province were being issued health cards by the government.
However, going by his tweets, it seemed that this was perhaps the only suggestion that was given due consideration while all the others were left unattended.
The list of recommendations that Vasay Chaudhry stated had been “carefully and passionately” prepared by the members of the council included:
- The launch of an international film festival in Lahore;
- Formation of a film authority in Punjab to support the revival of cinema in the province; (and)
- Restructuring of the current taxation on cinemas in Punjab.
He, however felt that there was no omen in sight that indicated towards the implementation – or even serious consideration – of these suggestions any time soon. Vasay further stated that he felt obligated to share this information with everyone as he had been part of meetings convened by the council that had been paid for from the tax-payer’s money.
Why Vasay Chaudhry’s Move to Resign Is Relevant
The term “culture” has often been exploited by various governments to garner support for actions that might otherwise meet with all out criticism.
The recent notification, issued by PEMRA advising television channels to not air content that delves on societal matters such as divorces and extramarital affairs is one such example. This action to curb creative freedom has also been justified under the pretext of preserving “culture.”
پیمرا کا تمام ٹی وی چینلز کو متنازعہ اور غیر اخلاقی موضوعات پر مبنی ڈراموں کی نشریات کو فوری روکنے کی ہدایت pic.twitter.com/J6QyzvKROq
— Report PEMRA (@reportpemra) January 8, 2019
The point that is important to consider is that while culture has been used as a scapegoat to justify grossly unfair policy practices, there has been little effort to actually preserve and propagate it.
It then makes a lot of sense for individuals like Vasay Chaudhry – who genuinely want to venture beyond rhetoric – to feel alienated by traditional bureaucratic practices.
Rather than indulging in further tokensim, it would serve the government better to pay serious heed to the words of those like Vasay Chadhry for whom “culture” is not an abstract word with an ever-evolving definition and function. It is only by deriving and learning from the experiences of artists that Pakistan can truly protect and promote its rich cultural legacy.